Benny Bradley's vs Potty Time Watch: Which Potty Training Watch Is Actually Better?
Benny Bradley's wins. It's water resistant (not just splash resistant), uses a rechargeable USB-C battery instead of disposable coin cells, and earns a higher Amazon rating (4.8★ vs 4.5★). Potty Time Watch costs $5 less, but Benny Bradley's durability and battery convenience make it the better long-term buy for most families.
📑 In This Article
Potty training watches are one of those tools that sound gimmicky until you're three weeks into training and your toddler suddenly responds to a cheerful alarm in a way they never responded to you saying "let's go potty" for the fourteenth time that morning. The right watch genuinely helps. The wrong one breaks, loses its battery at the worst moment, or gets destroyed in the bathtub.
The two most popular options right now are Benny Bradley's Potty Training Watch and the Potty Time Watch. Both show up in Amazon searches, both have solid reviews, and parents frequently ask which one is actually worth buying. After comparing specs, digging into reviews, and thinking through real-world toddler use, here's the full breakdown.
Feature Comparison: Benny Bradley's vs Potty Time Watch
Let's look at the key specs side by side before diving into what they mean in practice:
| Feature | Benny Bradley's | Potty Time Watch |
|---|---|---|
| Water Resistance | ✅ Water resistant | ⚠️ Splash resistant only |
| Battery | 🔋 USB-C rechargeable | 🪙 CR2032 coin cell |
| Reminder Intervals | 30 / 60 / 90 min | 30 / 60 / 90 min |
| Vibration Alerts | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Amazon Rating | ⭐ 4.8 stars | ⭐ 4.5 stars |
| Price | ~$20 | ~$15 |
Who Wins on Price?
Potty Time Watch wins on upfront cost — it's around $15 compared to Benny Bradley's $20, a $5 difference. For a tool your child might use for just a few months, that gap isn't nothing.
But here's the thing: the total cost of ownership is different from the sticker price. The Potty Time Watch runs on CR2032 coin cell batteries. Those cost $2–4 each at a drugstore, and if you're using the watch daily for 2–3 months of training, you'll likely replace the battery at least once or twice. More importantly, you'll always be hunting for CR2032s at inopportune moments — like when the watch dies at 7 PM and you're in the middle of a potty training session.
Benny Bradley's charges via USB-C, the same cable as most modern phones and tablets. You plug it in at night like any other device. No batteries to buy, no small parts for toddlers to find and swallow (CR2032s are a choking hazard), no dead watch mid-session.
Over 2–3 months of use, the real-world cost difference between these two watches is minimal. On pure sticker price, Potty Time wins. On total value, Benny Bradley's is competitive.
Who Wins on Durability?
Benny Bradley's wins on durability — and it's not close.
Think about where a potty training watch actually lives. It's on the wrist of a toddler who washes their hands many times a day (hopefully), splashes during bath time, plays in puddles, and generally treats everything they own as indestructible. Water is the enemy of most electronics.
Benny Bradley's is rated water resistant. That means it can handle being submerged briefly — like a toddler who refuses to take it off for bath time, or an accidental drop in the toilet (yes, this happens). Potty Time is splash resistant, which means light water contact is okay, but anything more risks damage.
In Amazon reviews, the most common Potty Time Watch complaints involve the watch stopping working after getting wet. With Benny Bradley's, water damage complaints are rare. For a product that lives on a toddler's wrist, this is a significant real-world advantage.
The 4.8★ vs 4.5★ Amazon rating gap is partly a reflection of this durability difference. A 0.3-star gap across hundreds of reviews represents meaningful differences in real parent experiences.
Who Wins for Travel?
Benny Bradley's wins here too, primarily because of the rechargeable battery.
When you're traveling — whether it's a road trip, a flight, or a week at grandma's house — you probably have USB-C chargers with you already. You're not going to have a CR2032 battery in your travel bag unless you specifically remembered to pack one. If the Potty Time Watch dies mid-trip, you're stuck finding a pharmacy or going without the watch entirely, which can derail progress you've worked hard to establish.
Benny Bradley's water resistance also matters more during travel. Kids are less supervised, more likely to be in unfamiliar bathrooms, and more likely to have unexpected water contact. The peace of mind of knowing the watch can handle real toddler conditions is worth something.
One area where Potty Time could edge ahead for travel is weight and size — but both watches are comparable in this regard, so it's essentially a wash.
Benny Bradley's Potty Training Watch
Water resistant, USB-C rechargeable, 4.8★ on Amazon. The watch that survives real toddler life — bath time, handwashing, and everything in between. Vibration + musical reminders at 30, 60, or 90 minute intervals.
Buy on Amazon →Overall Verdict: Which Should You Buy?
Buy Benny Bradley's if: you want the better-built, higher-rated watch that will survive your toddler's daily reality. The rechargeable battery is a genuine convenience advantage, the water resistance is a real durability advantage, and the higher Amazon rating reflects real parent satisfaction across hundreds of reviews. For $5 more than Potty Time, you're getting meaningfully better product.
Buy Potty Time if: budget is tight and $5 genuinely matters. It does everything the core job requires — timed reminders, vibration alerts, toddler-friendly design. If you're careful about keeping it dry and you don't mind swapping batteries, it'll get the job done.
For most families, Benny Bradley's is the right call. Potty training is already stressful without also worrying about whether your watch is going to survive bath time or whether you have the right battery on hand. The $5 price difference is worth eliminating those worries entirely.
Both watches serve the same fundamental purpose: giving your toddler an external cue to think about the potty, independent of you asking them. Research consistently shows that children respond differently to reminders that come from an object versus from a parent — there's less power struggle, less resistance, and more buy-in when the watch tells them it's time. Either of these watches delivers that benefit. Benny Bradley's just delivers it more reliably.
If you're still figuring out whether your child is ready for potty training at all, check out our guide on real signs your toddler is ready for potty training. And if you're considering an intensive approach, our article on how the naked potty training method works explains how to pair a potty watch with bare-bottom training for faster results.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best potty training watch overall?
Benny Bradley's Potty Training Watch is our top pick. It earns a 4.8-star rating on Amazon, offers true water resistance (not just splash resistance), charges via USB-C so you never need to buy coin cell batteries, and is priced around $20. For a few dollars more than the competition, you get a significantly more durable and convenient product.
Is Benny Bradley's potty watch actually waterproof?
It's water resistant, which is the more accurate term. This means it can handle submersion in shallow water briefly — like a toddler who won't take it off at bath time or an accidental drop in the sink. The Potty Time Watch, by comparison, is splash resistant only, meaning it can handle light water contact but not submersion. For a watch that lives on a toddler's wrist through daily handwashing and bath routines, water resistance is a major practical advantage.
Do potty training watches really work?
Yes, for many children. The key insight is that toddlers often respond better to a cue from an object than a reminder from a parent — it removes the power struggle element. The watch becomes the "boss" of potty time, not mom or dad. This works especially well for children who resist parental prompts but will cheerfully respond to a musical alarm. Neither Benny Bradley's nor Potty Time is magic, but used consistently as part of a broader potty training routine, they genuinely help many families.